Talk:The knight's sword

Reward

I received 20,225 Smithing experience when I was level 53 Smithing upon completing this quest, yet the reward states one receieves less experience than this upon completion. I'm not sure what we should write as the reward so if someone more experienced on this wiki please change it to be more accurate? Enyana 09:06, May 7, 2011 (UTC)

Reward formula

I calculated some formulas for reward xp. I'm almost certain some of the experiences posted are incorrect. Here is our data:

Level	XP
20	7,650
24	8,990
25	9,725
30	11,600
36	13,850
42	16,100
44	16,840
53	20,225
54	20,225

And here are some calculations:

Level:	Stated XP:	Formula: 375*(L+1)	Formula: 375*L+350	Formula: 374.12*L+262.16
20	7650	        7875	                7850	                7744.56
24	8990	        9375	                9350	                9241.04
25	9725	        9750	                9725	                9615.16
30	11600	        11625	                11600	                11485.76
36	13850	        13875	                13850	                13730.48
42	16100	        16125	                16100	                15975.2
44	16840	        16875	                16850	                16723.44
54	20225	        20625	                20600	                20464.64
53	20225	        20250	                20225	                20090.52
SUCCESSES:		0/9	                5/9	                0/9
DEVIATION:		0.9%                	0.7%	                -0.1%

I am thus posting the 375 * L + 350 XP formula. It has very small deviation even if it's wrong and it's more likely than the most accurate float number formula suggested by Excel. The first formula is most tempting since many other quests use similar to that but it got a success rate of 0% and the highest deviation.

RSC Mith (talk) 00:50, December 14, 2014 (UTC)

XP

I went from lvl 4 -> 14 smithing doing this quest. Zeus MC (talk) 08:21, December 14, 2014 (UTC)